The Bruise Brothers of Baseball All Stars

My Big Day with Phil & Joe Niekro, November 2005.

Thinking of the Niekro Brothers this morning lit a fire for putting together an All Star team comprised only of major league brothers. The following is the result of that thought. It may be short on left-handed pitching, but I’ll take my chances going into battle with these Bruise Brothers of Baseball any day of the week and twice on Sundays. The only selection rule I followed was the requirement of using at least two brothers from a family of MLB players.

Here’s the roster for The Baseball Bruise Brothers (Hall of Fame Members in bold type):


Pitching Staff:

* Dizzy Dean, P (150-83, 3.02 ERA)

* Phil Niekro, P (318-274, 3.35)

* Stan Coveleski, P (215-142, 2.89 ERA)

* Gaylord Perry, P (314-265, 3.11 ERA)

* Joe Niekro, P (221-204, 3.59 ERA)

Jim Perry, P (215-174, 3.45 ERA)

Paul Dean, P (87-37, 3.75)

Harry Coveleski, P (81-55, 2.39)

Bob Forsch, P (168-136, 3.76 ERA)

Ken Forsch, P (114-113, 3.37 ERA)

Cloyd Boyer, P (20-23, 4.73 ERA)

* The Five Starters

Position Players:

Sandy Alomar, Jr. C (.273 BA, 112 HR)

Luke Sewell, C (.259 BA, 20 HR)

Ed Delahanty, 1B (.346 BA, 101 HR)

Roberto Alomar, 2B (.300 BA, 210 HR)

Ken Boyer, 3B (.287 BA, 282 HR)

Joe Sewell, SS (.312 BA, 49 HR)

Clete Boyer, INF (,242 BA, 162 HR)

Jim Delahanty, INF (.283 BA, 19 HR)

Paul Waner, LF (.333 BA, 113 HR)

Joe DiMaggio, CF (.325, 361 HR)

Hank Aaron, RF (.305 BA, 755 HR)

Lloyd Waner, OF (.316 BA, 27 HR)

Dom DiMaggio, OF (.298 BA, 87 HR)

Tommy Aaron, OF (.229 BA, 27 HR)

Opening Day Lineup:

Paul Waner, LF

Joe Sewell, SS

Joe DiMaggio, CF

Hank Aaron, RF

Ken Boyer, 3B

Roberto Alomar, 2B

Ed Delahanty, 1B

Sandy Alomar, Jr., C

Dizzy Dean, P

That’s it for me, but let us know your own choices. There were plenty of others out there that qualify for a team of this type. Also, if you haven’t weighed in your support for the Houston Astros retirement of #36 in honor of Joe Niekro, please go over to the past column on that subject and check in with a statement.

Thanks. Here’s the Niekro article link:

https://thepecanparkeagle.wordpress.com/2010/07/13/its-time-to-retire-joe-niekros-astros-36/


Tags: ,

6 Responses to “The Bruise Brothers of Baseball All Stars”

  1. larry joe "Longball" miggins's avatar larry joe "Longball" miggins Says:

    How about Fran and Gus Mancuso. Famous brithers from H-Town?

    • Bill McCurdy's avatar Bill McCurdy Says:

      Larry: If filling the clubs with Houston guys had been my goal here, I would have started with Gus and Frank Mancuso. Trouble here is they are both catchers and top 2nd basemen and shortstops from the brothers group are tough to find. By taking Alomars and Sewells, we get two good catchers, plus a good second baseman and a Hall of Fame shortstop. That’s what drove the choices here. – Bill

  2. larry joe "Longball" miggins's avatar larry joe "Longball" miggins Says:

    I didn’t spell check, it should have read Frank and Gus Mancuso, Famous brothers from H-Town.

  3. Wayne Roberts's avatar Wayne Roberts Says:

    For us Houston folks, Bob and Ken Aspromonte………

  4. Mike McCroskey's avatar Mike McCroskey Says:

    I would be tempted to add the 40’s Cardinal bettery of Mort and Walker Cooper.

    Mort was 1942 MVP with a carfeer 2.97 ERA and Walker had 8+years of .300 or better including one monster year for the Giants when he slugged 35 homers.

  5. Tom Drake's avatar Tom Drake Says:

    What about the Alou brothers?

Leave a reply to Tom Drake Cancel reply