Is Danny Murtaugh Headed for the Hall of Fame?

On his big day in baseball, Pittsburgh Manager Danny Murtaugh (L) happily yielded the spotlight to his 2nd baseman, Bill Mazeroski.

Former Pittsburgh Pirate ace reliever Kent Tekulve may have said it best for a lot of Pittsburgh Pirate family members when he offered these choice comments about his former manager, the late  Danny Murtaugh, for two seasons in 1973-74: “”What I know about Murtaugh is there were two things you could count on. He would give you an honest evaluation or an honest answer, and you were rewarded for what you did on the field,” Tekulve said. “It didn’t matter who you were or what you looked like, he would stay with you as long as you performed. You always knew where you stood.”

Honesty, integrity, straight-shooting forthrightness, and a predictable record of rewarding those who got the job done with playing time are all qualities that lace their way through the comments of former Pirate players on Murtaugh – and they are now being heard loud enough to finally lift Danny Murtaugh into serious consideration by the Veterans Committee for future election to the Baseball hall of Fame.

For younger readers, a brief sketch of Danny Murtaugh’s career is in order.

Danny Murtaugh began his nine season Minor League career (1937-41, 1946-47, 1952-53) at Cambridge and concluding at New Orleans. He played second base for two really good Houston Buff clubs in 1940-41, hitting .299 and .317 on his way to the majors and a nine season Major League career with the Phillies, Braves, and Pirates (1941-43, 1946-51).

Murtaugh’s career minor league batting average was .297 with 16 homers. His career major league BA was .234 with 8 HR. Danny was more a speed guy who sprayed hits. As a 1941 rookie, Murtaugh’s 18 stolen bases led the National League.

It was as a manager that Danny Murtaugh stole the hearts of Pittsburgh fans and made his strong case for Hall of Fame consideration. As the Pirate field boss for all or part of 15 seasons over three decades (1957-64, 1976, 1971-71, 1973-76), Danny Murtaugh led Pittsburgh to five playoff contention seasons and two World Series championships in 1960 and 1971.

The 1960 World Series victory in seven games over Casey Stengel and the New York Yankees on the heels of Bill Mazeroski’s extra inning home run at Forbes Field is one of the signature moments in baseball history. It was a strong enough home run to eventually propel Bill Mazeroski into the Hall of Fame as a player – and it may yet have enough glow left about it to help manager Murtaugh be so duly honored too as a manager.

Let’s make this point clear. The 1960 Mazeroski home run to win the World Series may have been the deciding factor in earning enshrinement for Bill Mazeroski, but it cannot have been the only reason he got there. The man was one of the most athletic and sure-handed defensive second basemen in baseball history. He was richly deserving of the honor on these other qualities of talent and skill.

So it is with the late Danny Murtaugh. He doesn’t deserve the Hall of Fame for his shared “1960 Mazeroski Moment” alone, but for all he did as a manager to bring out the best in Pirates baseball for over three decades and twenty-nine total years of service to PittsburghPirates baseball as a player, coach, teacher, manager, and, yes, role model. Danny Murtaugh achieved by playing the game honestly with integrity. As I remember him, Danny also was the antithesis of Leo Durocher’s famously stuff-quoted expression on what happens to nice guys. Sometimes, when you are the kind of guy that Danny Murtaugh turned out to be, “nice guys finish first!”

Last fall, some of the folks in Pittsburgh got behind a movement to support Danny Murtaugh for induction into the Hall of Fame through a vote of support by the Veteran’s Committee. They came close, but walked away with no cigar. Danny Murtaugh received 8 of the possible 16 votes for Hall of Fame election. He needed 12 for induction and, who knows, maybe next year he will receive the kind of honor that this year passed to former manager Whitey Herzog.

Danny Murtaugh’s career managerial record at Pittsburgh is 1,115 wins against 950 losses. His uniform number 40 already has been retired by the Pittsburgh Pirate organization.

Unfortunately, Danny Murtaugh left us many years ago and at far too young an age. He died of a heart attack in 1976 at the age of 59.

Danny's Pirates won World Series titles in 1960 and 1971.

Murtaugh’s granddaughter, Colleen Hroncich, has written a biography on Danny that is supposed to be available now as “The Whistling Irishman: Danny Murtaugh Remembered.”  I have yet to see it, but here’s a website with information on its availablity:

http://dannymurtaughbook.com/

Also, if you have any strong feelings, one way or the other, on Danny Murtaugh’s qualification for the Hall of Fame, please leave a comment here as a reply to this article.

Thank you.

Tags: , ,

3 Responses to “Is Danny Murtaugh Headed for the Hall of Fame?”

  1. David Munger Says:

    I didn’t realize his career won loss record was that good. He had some
    bad teams leading up to ’60. That 1960 World Championship might be
    considered one of the biggest upsets in Baseball History.

    It’s sad, how many times have you turned on ESPN and one of the
    “TALKING HEADS” is saying, I don’t think a certain player or manager is worthy of The Hall of Fame. In Murtaugh’s case he died before a lot of these guys were born. When I was growing up, The Sporting News, The
    Houston Post, Chronicle, and Press along with my Baseball Cards were
    my Source for Sports.

    My dad played two years with Mazeroski. He said he was so quick getting the ball out of his glove, turning the double play, that they
    nicknamed him “NO TOUCH”.

  2. Shirley Virdon Says:

    Your comments on Danny Murtaugh’s possible election to the Baseball Hall of Fame are most welcome. Hopefully, if enough people keep his name in the news, he will gain the needed votes for election next year.
    Danny was not only an excellent manager, he was a fine human being and so was his wife, Kate. He was very instrumental in Bill’s becoming a Major League Manager. Bill learned so much from Danny and we have always treasured our years we spent with both Murtaughs!
    Danny’s book is available at Barnes & Noble. I bought mine from his granddaughter, Colleen, when she was in Bradenton at McKechnie Field on St. Patrick’s Day autographing the book.

    Re David Munger’s comments: Bill and I also enjoyed the time we spent with your parents in Cuba, St. Louis and Pittsburgh. They, too, were special people!

  3. Tommy Murtaugh Says:

    Hello, my name is Tommy, and i am Danny’s great great grandson, it always makes me happy when i search the internet to find articles like this written about him. I hope one day he is elected to the hall of fame, and his family is still very very into baseball. I basically dream, eat, breathe baseball! It is also to my knowledge that Danny Murtaugh’s son played baseball aswell, but only made it to the minor leagues

Leave a Reply to Shirley Virdon Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s


%d bloggers like this: