It’s hard to imagine that the ten worst clubs in big league baseball history fails to include even a single representative of the old St. Louis Browns, but failure is relative too when it comes to making it into the record book on the “biggest losers” list. This first list is also a little on the subjective side too. Pure losing percentages and “GB” from first place finishes would qualify as another list altogether. That being said the 1939 Browns deserve honorable mention for their 43-111 record and a last place finish that left the Amrican League Mound Citians some 64.5 games back of the first place World Champion New York Yankees.
The first “worst ten” list is the work of George Robinson and Charles Salzberg and it was published in 1991 by Dell as “Baseball’s Worst Teams: On A Clear Day They Could See Seventh Place.” Here’s their list in descending order from bad to worst. It’s hard for me to judge at least three of these clubs as worse than the 1939 St. Louis Browns:
Robinson-Salzberg Worst Big League Clubs List, 1899-1990:
(10) 1988 Baltimore Orioles, 54-107, 34.5 GB.
(9) 1979 Toronto Blue Jays, 53-109, 50.5 GB.
(8) 1962 New York Mets, 40-120, 60.5 GB.
(7) 1952 Pittsburgh Pirates, 42-112, 54.5 GB.
(6) 1942 Philadelphia Phillies, 42-109, 62.5 GB.
(5) 1935 Boston Braves, 38-115, 61.5 GB.
(4) 1928 Philadelphia Phillies, 43-109, 51 GB
(3) 1916 Philadelphia Athletics, 36-117, 54.5 GB
(2) 1904 Washington Senators, 38-113, 55.5 GB,
(1) 1899 Cleveland Senators. 20-134, 84 GB.
My own Ten Worst Clubs in Big League History is based upon a more objective standard of how many games behind the league leader each club finished for that competitive year. If failure truly is relative to worse comparable time and space failures and similar greater successes, then I’m going with “GB” (Games Behind the League Leader for that Particular Season) as the barometer I shall use. In the event of GB ties, the club with the worst winning percentage takes the higher negative position on my biggest loser list. (The issue of GB ties did not arise with my top ten worst clubs.)
My Biggest Loser Big League Club List, 1899-2009:
(10) 1927 Boston Red Sox, 51-103, 59 GB.
(9) 1954 Philadelphia Athletics, 51-103, 60 GB.
(8) 1962 New York Mets, 40-120, 60.5 GB.
(7) 1935 Boston Braves, 38-115, 61.5 GB.
(6) 1942 Philadelphia Phillies, 42-109, 62.5 GB.
(5) 1932 Boston Red Sox, 43-111, 64 GB.
(4) 1939 St. Louis Browns, 43-111, 64.5 GB.
(3) 1909 Boston Rustlers, 45-108, 65.5
(2) 1906 Boston Beaneaters, 49-102, 66.5 GB.
(1) 1899 Cleveland Spiders, 20-134, 84 GB.
Most of you know why the 1899 Cleveland Spiders pretty well locked up the worst club title forever by anyone’s measure. Their owner, Frank Robison, also owned the St. Louis Perfectos. Because of poor attendance in Cleveland for Spiders games, Robison moved all his best players to St. Louis and simply furnished the Spiders club with warm bodies. The results were a Cleveland team that barely won twenty games while finishing eighty-four games out of first place and a subsequent rule change to prohibit the syndicated or dual ownership of two big league clubs by a single person or group.
In my list, some of the lowest winners are missing, such as the 1904 Washington senators (38-113), but that club finished a mere 55.5 games behind the league leader, too shallow a grave for this GB-based listing of the most unfortunates.
If you can get inside their heads and hear that little voice that starts going off from about the third inning forward in some of the players, you will be able to pick your own list of biggest losers. They will be the clubs that have the most players whose little voices starting asking, “I wonder what we’re going to do to lose today?”
















