The two-homer game of Albert Pujols earlier this week has pushed the MLB 500 Plus HR Club membership to 26 men, with Pujols himself being the only active player in the group.
The 500 Plus MLB Home Run Club.
| RANK | NAME | HOME RUNS | HALL OF FAME? | STEROID CLOUD? |
| 1 | Barry Bonds | 762 | NO | YES |
| 2 | Hank Aaron | 755 | YES | NO |
| 3 | Babe Ruth | 714 | YES | NO |
| 4 | Willie Mays | 660 | YES | NO |
| 5 | Alex Rodriguez | 654 | Suspended | YES |
| 6 | Ken Griffey, Jr. | 630 | Eligible Soon | NO |
| 7 | Jim Thome | 612 | Eligible Soon | YES |
| 8 | JSammy Sosa | 609 | NO | YES |
| 9 | Frank Robinson | 586 | YES | NO |
| 10 | Mark McGwire | 583 | NO | YES |
| 11 | Harmon Killebrew | 573 | YES | NO |
| 12 | Rafael Palmeiro | 569 | NO | YES |
| 13 | Reggie Jackson | 563 | YES | NO |
| 14 | Manny Ramirez | 555 | Eligible Soon | YES |
| 15 | Mike Schmidt | 548 | YES | NO |
| 16 | Mickey Mantle | 536 | YES | NO |
| 17 | Jimmie Foxx | 534 | YES | NO |
| 18 t | Willie McCovey | 521 | YES | NO |
| 18 t | Frank Thomas | 521 | YES – 2014 | NO |
| 18 t | Ted Williams | 521 | YES | NO |
| 21 t | Ernie Banks | 512 | YES | NO |
| 21 t | Eddie Mathews | 512 | YES | NO |
| 23 | Mel Ott | 511 | YES | NO |
| 24 | Gary Sheffield | 509 | Eligible Soon | YES |
| 25 | Eddie Murray | 504 | YES | NO |
| 26 | Albert Pujols | 500 | Active Player | ? Don’t Know |
Of the 26 men who have hit 500 plus home runs in their major league careers, 15 of the 26 men (57.7%) have already been admitted to the Baseball Hall f Fame,
Among those 15 members of the Hall of Fame, none, unless you count the few extremists who suspected new member Frank Thomas for having a powerful, muscular body, and I don’t, were suspected of using steroids during their careers.
Of the remaining players, only one of the 11 have been clearly established as a non-steroids-clouded person. That would be Ken Griffey, Jr. Those who come up for induction at least once, so far, have all failed to receive the 75% support that each candidate needs for induction.
For now, it is the miscreant players who are paying he price for doing what Messrs. McGwire and Sosa made so famous in the summer of 1998, saving baseball from the strike year of 1994 and making it all the way to the then important cover of Time magazine on the juice.
And they did all that salvation work without the owners ever knowing about the steroids? I guess. I guess it’s just like 1919 all over again – when only the players were dirty – and the owners were clean.
Sometimes two-faced people are so carried away sometimes by a subtle to not-so-subtle personal conviction in their own brilliance and mastery of denial and slight-of-hand that they either forget or lose sight of the fact that it is still possible to kill the Golden Goose business that has paid all their dream barrels for a century, at least.
It isn’t the empty seats that any major league club needs to fear. It’s what caused them to be empty that’s the heart of the problem. And for everyday empty seats, it won’t be lousy baseball that does it, or direct competition with an NFL or NBA home game in the same city on the same day, or the lack of a way to follow the team on television due to the general malaise into inaction fed by greed, or even school starting early tomorrow that has ground things to halt. It’s indifference. – If that day’s does come home, it will be the drooling beast of apathy that kills the beauty of our dear beloved baseball.
Let’s work against that taking positive action. Here are a few suggestions:
(1) Wait until we get a new commissioner to even try;
(2) Ask the new commissioner to appoint a special panel to consider all the eligible HOF candidates whose way to the Hall may simply be blocked by them being seen as members of that “dirty group.”
(3) Ask the Steroids Candidate Committee to examine the records of each player for the presence of accomplishments too large to ignore versus the presence of proven offenses that are too large, to date, to ignore.
(4) Expect the SC Committee to hrow out hearsay, innuendo, and improperly handled evidence. Go with what is evidential to date as a basis for approval or denial.
(5) If a man is innocent, or not proven guilty, and he deserves the HOF for his accomplishments, either take him into the HOF and recognize his accomplishments accordingly – or else, ban him for life and further consideration.
(6) Don’t ignore a suspect by leaving him in the regular voting line with the kind of support that normally goes to .210 hitters and 6.00 ERA pitchers.
(7) No man should be left to twist in the wind of uncertainty. Unless we can come up with a way that realistically proves that steroids may create greatness, it seems to me that we need to recognize those who set or broke records during the “owners look the other way” steroids era, while doing all we can to make sure it never happens again.
That would do for a start. And it would beat ignoring Bonds and McGwire and Clemens as human beings who once did great things on the diamond that were not all caused by steroids.
I may be wrong, but it’s been my experience that wrongs we treat as non-events lead to apathy and repetition – and not to healing.
What do you think?

April 26, 2014 at 2:31 am |
I agree that players like Bonds and Clemens were too good to be denied entry into the Hall of Fame. They surely padded their statistics by prolonging their careers and enhancing their abilities with steroids and/or other PEDs, but they would have had HOF statistics without the use of drugs (that, to me, is what makes their use of PEDs so sad – they didn’t have to do it).
As for Mark McGwire, I don’t think he belongs in the HOF. I compare McGwire to Dave Kingman, who is not and does not belong in the Hall. Both players either homered, singled, or K’d; they didn’t do much else with the bat, and they weren’t defensive wizards either. If McGwire hadn’t taken PEDs, then his homer total would probably be on a par with Kingman’s and he wouldn’t even be in the conversation about HOF induction.
One last thought I have concerns Ken Griffey, Jr. I have often wondered why he gets a free pass on PED suspicion. If practically every player from his era falls under this cloud of suspicion in some way, then Griffey certainly seems questionable as well. He had those two consecutive 56-homer seasons with the Mariners which were monster homer totals just like McGwire, Sosa, and other PED users put up. Then, after he went to Cincinnati, he had a season-ending injury almost every year, which just seems like the sort of body-breakdown that most PED users eventually suffered. He also transformed from the smiling Kid that everyone adored into a grumpy old man (‘roid rage?). It’s unfortunate that I’ve become so cynical about the players, but that’s what the Steroids Era has done to a lot of baseball fans. I trust no ballplayers anymore.
April 28, 2014 at 7:12 am |
I agree Bill.
“A little neglect may breed great mischief.”
–Vietnamese slogan
May 1, 2014 at 1:58 pm |
I just finished the ted Williams book the kid by Ben Bradlee jr. Great book and I will send to you if you are interested. Also has there ever been another Puddinhead as in Puddinhead Jones of the Phillies?.
May 1, 2014 at 2:17 pm |
Good Morning, Dr. Matlosz!
Yes, I would love the new Williams book. Just send it to me at PO BOX 940871, Houston, TX 77094-7871.
And don’t forget to come to Houston this fall and I will take you to the UH home game of your choice at the new (as of yet named) UH stadium.
Regards, Bill